Writer’s note: The second paragraph of this article (just below the first image) contains a basic outline of the film’s premise. There are no spoilers that weren’t already inferred in the film’s own trailer. However, if you want to completely avoid potential spoilers, skip over the second paragraph.
Few films are as iconic as Ridley Scott’s horror masterpiece, Alien (1979). After being initially met with a mixed reaction, Alien was quickly reevaluated as a timeless modern classic, deftly blending realistic science fiction, relatable characters, unnerving terror, artistic craftsmanship, and thought provoking ideas into a seamless whole. Not to mention that the film also delivered one of the greatest heroes of all time in Sigourney Weaver’s Ellen Ripley, as well as one of the most terrifying villains in the titular Alien. Its immediate sequel, Aliens (1986), is just as revered, as director James Cameron expanded on the original’s excellence, and added a healthy dose of nail-biting action. Between these two films, it’s arguable that there hasn’t been higher quality blockbusters before or since. This is especially true of the resulting Alien franchise, which has been a deluge of disappointment for the last 30 years. Alien: Romulus (2024) is the latest attempt to bring the series back to its former glory.

Set in between the events of Alien and Aliens, we are introduced to Rain (Cailee Spaeny) a young, orphaned miner working for the Weyland-Yutani company on the colonised planet, Jackson’s Star. She slaves away with her adopted brother Andy (David Jonsson), who is a synthetic human android (or artificial person) created by Rain’s father. Along with many of the colonists, Rain wishes to be released from her contract to the company and flee to the planet Yvaga, but there’s no hope of ever gaining enough credits under Weyland-Yutani’s exploitative policies. Rain’s ex-boyfriend Tyler (Archie Renaux) convinces her to join a small expedition to a derelict spacecraft called The Romulus, where they hope to find cryostasis chambers they can use to safely travel to Yvaga. Rain, Andy, Tyler and the others, Kay (Isabela Merced), Bjorn (Spike Fearn) and Navarro (Alieen Wu) go to Romulus, but things don’t go as planned when they discover that the ship is infested with the terrifying Aliens.
Ever since the original series ended with the fourth film, Alien: Resurrection (1997), the franchise continued to become an embarrassing husk with the crossover films, Alien vs. Predator (2004) and Alien vs. Predator – Requiem (2007). Following that, Ridley Scott returned to the franchise in Prometheus (2012) and Alien: Covenant (2017), with the aim of fleshing out the origins of the Alien, as well as highlighting the philosophical themes. Despite Scott being the originator, Prometheus and Covenant did little to put Alien back on top. These films made the mythology far too convoluted, and they missed the point of the original films. Alien and Aliens had a simple yet effective premise, and they had no need for further explanation. We didn’t need to know where the Alien came from, nor did we need the films to flesh out themes of creationism. This series desperately needed to remind viewers that it works best as a scary and character driven thriller. Director Fede Álvarez seems to understand this with Alien: Romulus.

Given that the signature Alien has been an iconic movie monster for nearly 50 years, it’s no wonder that the series has struggled to elicit legitimate tension. Álvarez brings Alien: Romulus back to basics, constructing a collection of sequences geared towards creating genuine fear. The familiar elements of the Alien films are all on display, yet Álvarez uses them in unique and creative ways. As with all the best horror films, Alien: Romulus refrains from delivering everything all at once, instead building the fear by only showing small pieces of the danger little by little. This means that Alien: Romulus never feels repetitive, never wears out its welcome, and maintains an energetic pace. At the start we’re only seeing the creepy FaceHuggers, and by the end we’re seeing the fully grown Aliens. All of this is especially impressive considering the film’s modest budget, which pales in comparison to most visual effects heavy blockbusters.
Regardless, it’s not the spectacle which makes Alien: Romulus notable, but rather that the film reinforces the main point of the original film. The concept alone was scary for simply having an Alien stalk and kill a group of people, but the 1979 film also evoked a very real fear of sexual assault. This is what made the Alien so unnerving for audiences. The imagery of the monster was incredibly phallic, and the method in which it killed was incredibly violating. When women watched the film, they recognised the fear the Alien presented, and men could finally understand that same fear. This is also why the film had a woman at its centre, as there was something very cathartic about seeing Ellen Ripley fight and defeat the monster. This thematic resonance has been largely forgotten, but Álvarez has made sure it’s front and centre with Alien: Romulus. Álvarez makes the allegorical imagery unmistakable, once again ensuring that an Alien film makes everyone in the audience feel unnerved. The highlighted phallic and sexual imagery may be too much for some viewers, but even that proves it’s effective.

Despite the many considerable merits, Alien: Romulus isn’t without its fair share of problems. Most frustratingly, nearly all of its problems could’ve easily been avoided. Yes, Alien: Romulus consolidates all of the most notable aspects of the Alien franchise, and that includes the worst aspects of the most recent films. Specifically, Alien: Romulus’ midpoint introduces silly and overly complicated elements from Prometheus and Alien: Covenant. While these aspects are handled fine here (and wouldn’t be too bothersome to viewers who never saw those previous entries) it can’t help but create some confusion. For viewers who understand the deeper context, the rest of the storytelling will suffer. The most aggravating part of all this is that these story points are so clearly tacked on to a script which doesn’t need them. So while it’s clear these issues could’ve been avoided, corporate decisions ensured that the film was never going to escape them.
With that in mind, this is key as to why Alien: Romulus can’t quite escape the shadow of Alien or Aliens. Ultimately, very obvious studio notes actively prevent the film from becoming something more. There’s no reason why this story needs to be loaded with references to the original films, yet Alien: Romulus is populated with them anyway. This is frustrating, as Álvarez is a highly skilled filmmaker, with his imagination being displayed throughout the many tense sequences. Nearly every time Álvarez is allowed to run wild with a clever or exciting idea, his thunder is stolen by some kind of callback to the earlier franchise. Just imagine if James Cameron was told to constantly reference Ridley Scott’s Alien. If that happened, it’s likely Aliens wouldn’t be as great as it is. This even applies to the highly flawed Alien 3 (1995) and Alien: Resurrection (1997). Directors David Fincher and Jean-Pierre Jeunet didn’t deliver good Alien films, but they were given the chance to try new things. Alien: Romulus is so close to being Álvarez’s completely unique vision, but slavish reverence to earlier films unfortunately stifles that.

All that being said, Alien: Romulus is still a return to form for the franchise. Even if it’s not an unassailable masterpiece like the original two films, it’s still leaps and bounds ahead of practically every other entry. If only director Fede Álvarez was given the chance to work without people looking over his shoulder, it’s very possible we could’ve been given the first truly excellent Alien film in decades. As it stands, we have to settle for a good one.
6.5/10

